| A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. | |
|
+5DJTFresh Hightree39 Idriaka Mr. Ex Vice President Ster Zetanee 9 posters |
Author | Message |
---|
Ster Zetanee Master of Skittles
Posts : 155 Join date : 2012-10-25 Age : 33 Location : Purdue
| Subject: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 10:38 am | |
| He averaged the place people ranked every pony, and the best pony would be the one with the best average place. Game interesting Results. - Spoiler:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
OK here is the quiz it used. [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]YOUR PRINCESS REQUESTS THAT ALL POSTS OF THE RESULTS TO THE QUIZ BE SPOILERS SO THAT THE POST OVERALL IS NOT CLUTTERED WITH WALLS OF TEXT.
Last edited by Ster Zetanee on Tue Feb 19, 2013 3:16 pm; edited 2 times in total | |
|
| |
Mr. Ex Vice President King of the Griffons
Posts : 112 Join date : 2012-10-26
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 11:03 am | |
| If I'm reading that right, the sample size = 28 people I'm going to go out on a limb and say this is not a very good study. There is absolutely no reason why Rarity and Sweetie Belle would be the top 2 (consider this: Rarity is awful) | |
|
| |
Idriaka Junior Speedster
Posts : 62 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 33
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 1:45 pm | |
| Bah, reddit, why must you always upload text as giant images.
Yeah I don't know what the sample size is or if this is representative at all, but Sweetie Belle did tie for first with Celestia on mine so i say:
PERFECTLY ACCURATE. | |
|
| |
Ster Zetanee Master of Skittles
Posts : 155 Join date : 2012-10-25 Age : 33 Location : Purdue
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 3:14 pm | |
| - Mr. Vice President wrote:
- If I'm reading that right, the sample size = 28 people
I'm going to go out on a limb and say this is not a very good study. There is absolutely no reason why Rarity and Sweetie Belle would be the top 2 (consider this: Rarity is awful) I missed the sample size, but that's reddit for you. I would be curious to the results if this survey was done by a larger sample. - Spoiler:
Rank Character 1 Rainbow Dash 1 Princess Luna 3 Applejack 3 Queen Chrysalis 5 Lyra 6 Twilight Sparkle 6 Fluttershy 6 Discord 9 Pinkie Pie 9 Princess Celestia 11 Cloud Chaser 12 Spitfire 13 Apple Bloom 14 Soarin' 15 Octavia 16 Rarity 16 Spike 16 Princess Cadence 16 Cheerilee 16 Big Macintosh 21 Vinyl Scratch 22 Derpy 23 Dr. Whooves 23 Trixie 25 Nightmare Moon 25 Shining Armor 27 Flitter 28 Rose Luck 28 Berry Punch 30 Sweetie Belle 30 Granny Smith 30 Pipsqueak 33 Braeburn 34 Carrot Top 34 Zecora 36 Bon Bon 37 Scootaloo 38 Flim 38 Flam 38 Diamond Tiara 38 Iron Will 38 Fleur de Lys 43 Snowflake / Horsepower 44 Silver Spoon 44 Colgate 44 Caramel 44 Babs Seed 44 Twist 49 Fancy Pants 50 Lightning Dust 51 Photo Finish 51 Hoity Toity 51 Prince Blueblood 54 Gilda 55 King Sombra
If everyone does that quiz and posts the results here I will try and do the calculations for our club. would be interesting in my opinion anyways.
Last edited by Ster Zetanee on Tue Feb 19, 2013 3:26 pm; edited 1 time in total | |
|
| |
Mr. Ex Vice President King of the Griffons
Posts : 112 Join date : 2012-10-26
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 3:24 pm | |
| - Ster Zetanee wrote:
- I would be curious to the results if this survey was done by a larger sample.
As I recall, this year's brony census had a "favorite pony" type deal with all of the characters in a non-ordered ambiguous ranking system. That'll be a lot better, as it rated each character individually as opposed to relative to each other. | |
|
| |
Ster Zetanee Master of Skittles
Posts : 155 Join date : 2012-10-25 Age : 33 Location : Purdue
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 3:31 pm | |
| Yeah, it will be better overall, but I though the idea of how the survey was being done on Reddit was interesting because it didn't go by who was the most commonly said to be the best pony, but instead who was the highest on every single list. It shows who is overall mot liked among the ponies rather than best pony. Results when i did the quiz. - Spoiler:
Rank Character 1 Rainbow Dash 1 Applejack 1 Princess Luna 4 Cloud Chaser 5 Fluttershy 5 Queen Chrysalis 5 Discord 5 Lyra 9 Twilight Sparkle 9 Princess Celestia 9 Nightmare Moon 9 Derpy 9 Dr. Whooves 9 Octavia 9 Spitfire 16 Vinyl Scratch 16 Soarin' 18 Apple Bloom 18 Trixie 20 Pinkie Pie 21 Rarity 21 Spike 21 Princess Cadence 21 Shining Armor 21 Big Macintosh 21 Flitter 27 Cheerilee 27 Rose Luck 27 Twist 27 Snowflake / Horsepower 31 Granny Smith 31 Carrot Top 31 Zecora 34 Pipsqueak 35 Sweetie Belle 35 Scootaloo 37 Bon Bon 37 Colgate 37 Berry Punch 37 Braeburn 37 Lightning Dust 37 Hoity Toity 43 Babs Seed 44 Caramel 45 Flim 45 Flam 45 Diamond Tiara 45 Silver Spoon 45 Iron Will 45 King Sombra 45 Gilda 45 Photo Finish 45 Fleur de Lys 54 Fancy Pants 54 Prince Blueblood
MUCH BETTER
This quiz does some have some short cuts in it because some antagonists I really dislike are higher than ponies I am neutral towards. If everyone does that quiz and posts the results here I will try and do the calculations for our club. would be interesting in my opinion anyways. | |
|
| |
Idriaka Junior Speedster
Posts : 62 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 33
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 5:58 pm | |
| Datas - Spoiler:
1 Princess Celestia 1 Sweetie Belle 3 Twilight Sparkle 4 Rarity 5 Rainbow Dash 6 Fluttershy 7 Pinkie Pie 8 Applejack 9 Discord 10 Apple Bloom 11 Scootaloo 12 Spike 13 Queen Chrysalis 14 Princess Luna 15 Zecora 16 Big Macintosh 17 Gilda 18 Photo Finish 19 Cheerilee 20 Lyra 21 Iron Will 22 Shining Armor 23 Trixie 24 Derpy 25 Fancy Pants 26 Bon Bon 27 Nightmare Moon 28 Caramel 29 Octavia 30 Rose Luck 31 Granny Smith 31 Vinyl Scratch 33 Braeburn 34 Snowflake / Horsepower 35 Flitter 36 Cloud Chaser 37 Hoity Toity 38 Princess Cadence 38 Pipsqueak 40 Fleur de Lys 41 Lightning Dust 42 Colgate 43 Spitfire 44 Soarin' 45 Babs Seed 46 Silver Spoon 47 Twist 48 Berry Punch 49 Dr. Whooves 50 Carrot Top 51 Diamond Tiara 52 Prince Blueblood 53 Flim 53 Flam 53 King Sombra
| |
|
| |
Hightree39 The Humanized
Posts : 198 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 30 Location : That voice in your head
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 6:05 pm | |
| I might as well join in. - Spoiler:
1 Applejack 1 Spike 1 Discord 1 Shining Armor 1 Scootaloo 1 Big Macintosh 1 Pipsqueak 1 Iron Will 1 Lyra 1 Dr. Whooves 1 Zecora 1 Soarin' 1 Spitfire 1 Braeburn 1 Babs Seed 1 Gilda 17 Twilight Sparkle 17 Rainbow Dash 17 Princess Luna 17 Apple Bloom 17 King Sombra 22 Fluttershy 22 Pinkie Pie 22 Derpy 22 Snowflake / Horsepower 26 Rarity 26 Octavia 26 Vinyl Scratch 29 Berry Punch 30 Bon Bon 31 Nightmare Moon 32 Princess Celestia 33 Princess Cadence 33 Queen Chrysalis 33 Sweetie Belle 33 Cheerilee 33 Granny Smith 33 Flim 33 Flam 33 Diamond Tiara 33 Silver Spoon 33 Colgate 33 Carrot Top 33 Caramel 33 Fancy Pants 46 Lightning Dust 47 Rose Luck 47 Cloud Chaser 47 Flitter 50 Photo Finish 50 Fleur de Lys 52 Hoity Toity 52 Prince Blueblood 54 Trixie
| |
|
| |
DJTFresh Bass Cannoneer
Posts : 80 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 30 Location : Classified
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 7:11 pm | |
| I find the lack of wub for Vinyl disturbing | |
|
| |
Mr. Ex Vice President King of the Griffons
Posts : 112 Join date : 2012-10-26
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 7:16 pm | |
| - Spoiler:
1 Princess Luna 1 Shining Armor 1 Scootaloo 1 Fancy Pants 5 Twilight Sparkle 5 Rainbow Dash 7 Soarin' 7 Spitfire 9 Fluttershy 10 Pinkie Pie 11 Trixie 12 Spike 12 Sweetie Belle 12 Apple Bloom 15 Braeburn 15 Babs Seed 17 Flam 18 Princess Cadence 18 Discord 18 Nightmare Moon 18 Lightning Dust 22 Princess Celestia 23 Applejack 24 Octavia 24 Vinyl Scratch 26 Iron Will 26 Lyra 26 Snowflake / Horsepower 29 Derpy 29 Dr. Whooves 31 Big Macintosh 32 Flim 33 Carrot Top 33 Fleur de Lys 35 Queen Chrysalis 36 Pipsqueak 37 Rarity 38 Cloud Chaser 38 Flitter 40 Cheerilee 40 Granny Smith 42 Diamond Tiara 42 Silver Spoon 42 Bon Bon 42 Rose Luck 42 Colgate 42 Berry Punch 42 Zecora 42 Gilda 42 Photo Finish 42 Hoity Toity 52 Caramel 53 King Sombra 53 Prince Blueblood 55 Twist
Rainbow Dash only came up once. She should be higher. (#1)
Interesting to note: Vinyl Scratch and Octavia are the same rank, as well as Derpy and Dr. Whooves, and Soarin' and Spitfire, and Flitter and Cloudchaser, and Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon, and Discord and Nightmare Moon.
Flim and Flam are far separated, and considering that I treated them as equal, that shows that there is some major error in this calculation method. Hella coincidence in some of these ranks | |
|
| |
Ster Zetanee Master of Skittles
Posts : 155 Join date : 2012-10-25 Age : 33 Location : Purdue
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Tue Feb 19, 2013 7:42 pm | |
| Yeah, depending on how you vote in the first like 30 questions it will really mess up the order, I took it twice to sort that out for mine. | |
|
| |
MegaCereal The Pony
Posts : 37 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 32
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Wed Feb 20, 2013 11:53 am | |
| Here is my contribution. - Spoiler:
1 Fluttershy 1 Pipsqueak 1 Berry Punch 4 Derpy 5 Snowflake / Horsepower 6 Rainbow Dash 6 Iron Will 8 Princess Luna 9 Spitfire 10 Pinkie Pie 11 Colgate 12 Scootaloo 13 Princess Celestia 14 Nightmare Moon 15 Trixie 16 Fancy Pants 17 Hoity Toity 18 Dr. Whooves 19 Lyra 20 Twilight Sparkle 21 Discord 22 Big Macintosh 23 Sweetie Belle 24 Photo Finish 25 Octavia 26 Vinyl Scratch 27 Spike 28 Shining Armor 29 Queen Chrysalis 30 Princess Cadence 31 Rose Luck 32 Rarity 33 Cloud Chaser 34 Applejack 34 Soarin' 36 Bon Bon 37 Cheerilee 38 Twist 39 Flim 39 Fleur de Lys 41 Prince Blueblood 42 Babs Seed 43 Braeburn 44 Flam 45 Apple Bloom 46 Granny Smith 47 Flitter 48 Carrot Top 49 Diamond Tiara 50 Zecora 51 Silver Spoon 52 Caramel 53 King Sombra 54 Lightning Dust 55 Gilda
| |
|
| |
Zodo Junior Speedster
Posts : 50 Join date : 2012-10-30 Age : 54 Location : Lafayette
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Thu Feb 21, 2013 9:57 am | |
| My results... - Spoiler:
1 Scootaloo 2 Big Macintosh 3 Applejack 4 Zecora 5 Fluttershy 6 Rainbow Dash 7 Princess Luna 8 Trixie 9 Queen Chrysalis 10 Nightmare Moon 11 Discord 12 Gilda 13 Dr. Whooves 14 Lightning Dust 15 Babs Seed 16 Granny Smith 17 Pinkie Pie 18 Iron Will 19 Shining Armor 20 Apple Bloom 21 Rarity 22 Sweetie Belle 23 Spike 24 Snowflake / Horsepower 25 Derpy 26 Princess Celestia 27 Twilight Sparkle 28 Vinyl Scratch 29 Soarin' 29 Spitfire 29 Braeburn 32 Silver Spoon 32 Colgate 32 Octavia 32 Carrot Top 32 Caramel 32 Fancy Pants 38 Hoity Toity 39 Photo Finish 40 Cheerilee 40 Rose Luck 40 Berry Punch 40 Cloud Chaser 40 Flitter 45 Princess Cadence 46 Prince Blueblood 47 Diamond Tiara 48 Flim 48 Lyra 48 Bon Bon 48 Twist 48 Fleur de Lys 53 King Sombra 54 Pipsqueak 55 Flam
| |
|
| |
DJTFresh Bass Cannoneer
Posts : 80 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 30 Location : Classified
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Thu Feb 21, 2013 1:41 pm | |
| - Spoiler:
1 Vinyl Scratch 2 Twilight Sparkle 2 Rainbow Dash 4 Princess Celestia 5 Princess Luna 6 Queen Chrysalis 7 Discord 7 Nightmare Moon 9 Spitfire 10 Princess Cadence 11 Shining Armor 12 Trixie 13 Iron Will 14 Lightning Dust 15 Gilda 16 Fluttershy 17 Octavia 18 Soarin' 19 Dr. Whooves 20 Derpy 21 Applejack 22 Spike 23 Lyra 24 King Sombra 25 Zecora 26 Rarity 27 Pinkie Pie 28 Scootaloo 29 Bon Bon 30 Cloud Chaser 31 Colgate 32 Carrot Top 33 Sweetie Belle 34 Big Macintosh 34 Flam 36 Apple Bloom 36 Pipsqueak 38 Cheerilee 38 Granny Smith 40 Flim 41 Flitter 41 Twist 43 Snowflake / Horsepower 43 Photo Finish 45 Prince Blueblood 46 Fancy Pants 47 Fleur de Lys 48 Silver Spoon 48 Rose Luck 48 Berry Punch 48 Babs Seed 52 Hoity Toity 53 Braeburn 53 Caramel 55 Diamond Tiara YOUR PRINCESS HAS EDITED THIS POST TO REMOVE CLUTTER FROM THE POST. THIS WILL BE DONE TO ALL POST IN THIS TOPIC, THAT FORGET TO SPOILER THEIR POST. | |
|
| |
MintShard The Pony
Posts : 32 Join date : 2012-11-02 Age : 32 Location : West Lafillyette
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Fri Feb 22, 2013 11:53 am | |
| My results: - Spoiler:
1 Twilight Sparkle 1 Rainbow Dash 1 Princess Luna 1 Princess Cadence 1 Discord 1 Nightmare Moon 1 Lyra 1 Bon Bon 1 Derpy 1 Vinyl Scratch 11 Pinkie Pie 11 Princess Celestia 11 Queen Chrysalis 11 Shining Armor 11 Sweetie Belle 11 Apple Bloom 11 Scootaloo 18 Fluttershy 18 Cheerilee 18 Rose Luck 18 Colgate 18 Octavia 18 Carrot Top 18 Babs Seed 18 Cloud Chaser 26 Berry Punch 26 Spitfire 26 Flitter 29 Lightning Dust 30 Rarity 30 Applejack 30 Braeburn 30 Photo Finish 30 Fleur de Lys 35 Dr. Whooves 35 Zecora 37 Big Macintosh 37 Soarin' 39 Caramel 39 Fancy Pants 41 Flim 41 Flam 43 Granny Smith 43 Trixie 43 Hoity Toity 46 King Sombra 47 Spike 47 Twist 47 Snowflake / Horsepower 47 Prince Blueblood 51 Pipsqueak 51 Iron Will 51 Gilda 54 Diamond Tiara 54 Silver Spoon
| |
|
| |
DJTFresh Bass Cannoneer
Posts : 80 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 30 Location : Classified
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Fri Feb 22, 2013 2:34 pm | |
| How DO you do spoilertext | |
|
| |
MintShard The Pony
Posts : 32 Join date : 2012-11-02 Age : 32 Location : West Lafillyette
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Fri Feb 22, 2013 2:55 pm | |
| When you start a new post, click other and pick spoiler. Then type between the two [spoiler]'s | |
|
| |
alpha142 The President
Posts : 354 Join date : 2012-10-26 Location : Tamriel
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Sun Feb 24, 2013 3:53 am | |
| Here is my list. I was a bit indecisive. - Spoiler:
Rank Character 1 Fluttershy 1 Derpy 3 Twilight Sparkle 4 Princess Luna 5 Sweetie Belle 6 Scootaloo 7 Octavia 7 Vinyl Scratch 9 Pinkie Pie 10 Princess Celestia 10 Queen Chrysalis 12 Nightmare Moon 13 Discord 14 Big Macintosh 15 Lyra 16 Berry Punch 17 Rainbow Dash 18 Applejack 19 Fancy Pants 20 Babs Seed 21 Spike 22 Zecora 23 Apple Bloom 24 Princess Cadence 25 Shining Armor 26 Flitter 27 Trixie 28 Fleur de Lys 29 Rose Luck 30 Colgate 31 Rarity 32 Cheerilee 33 Bon Bon 34 Spitfire 35 Dr. Whooves 36 Snowflake / Horsepower 37 Iron Will 38 Granny Smith 38 Flim 40 Carrot Top 41 King Sombra 42 Braeburn 43 Cloud Chaser 44 Soarin' 45 Flam 45 Diamond Tiara 45 Silver Spoon 45 Pipsqueak 49 Caramel 49 Twist 49 Gilda 49 Lightning Dust 49 Photo Finish 49 Hoity Toity 49 Prince Blueblood
| |
|
| |
DJTFresh Bass Cannoneer
Posts : 80 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 30 Location : Classified
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Sun Feb 24, 2013 3:55 am | |
| Well at least vinyl is in your top ten.... | |
|
| |
alpha142 The President
Posts : 354 Join date : 2012-10-26 Location : Tamriel
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Sun Feb 24, 2013 3:57 am | |
| I enjoy Vinyl as a character, but it is kind of hard to separate her from Octavia. | |
|
| |
DJTFresh Bass Cannoneer
Posts : 80 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 30 Location : Classified
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Sun Feb 24, 2013 2:18 pm | |
| WHAAAAAAT? Its easy, one is best pony, one plays..'*shudders*...string instruments My jimmies.....nuuu | |
|
| |
Idriaka Junior Speedster
Posts : 62 Join date : 2012-10-26 Age : 33
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. Fri Mar 01, 2013 2:19 am | |
| Oh hey, an episode variant of the ranking page. [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]- Spoiler:
1 Green Isn't Your Color 2 Party of One 3 Putting Your Hoof Down 4 Winter Wrap Up 5 Sweet and Elite 6 The Return of Harmony 7 Sisterhooves Social 8 Friendship is Magic 9 Feeling Pinkie Keen 10 Keep Calm and Flutter On 11 Lesson Zero 12 Fall Weather Friends 13 The Ticket Master 14 A Canterlot Wedding 15 Suited for Success 16 Dragonshy 17 Just For Sidekicks 18 Stare Master 19 Sleepless in Ponyville 20 Griffon the Brush-Off 21 Sonic Rainboom 22 Magical Mystery Cure 23 A Dog and Pony Show 24 Hurricane Fluttershy 25 Too Many Pinkie Pies 26 Bridle Gossip 27 Swarm of the Century 28 Boast Busters 29 Baby Cakes 29 Hearth's Warming Eve 31 May the Best Pet Win! 32 A Friend in Deed 33 It's About Time 34 Games Ponies Play 35 Applebuck Season 36 The Best Night Ever 37 Magic Duel 38 The Cutie Mark Chronicles 39 A Bird in the Hoof 40 One Bad Apple 41 Luna Eclipsed 42 Call of the Cutie 43 Over a Barrel 44 Look Before You Sleep 45 Ponyville Confidential 45 MMMystery on the Friendship Express 45 The Crystal Empire 48 The Cutie Pox 49 The Show Stoppers 50 Owl's Well That Ends Well 50 Read It and Weep 52 Hearts and Hooves Day 53 The Mysterious Mare Do Well 53 Secret of My Excess 53 Family Appreciation Day 53 The Last Roundup 53 The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000 58 Dragon Quest 59 Spike at Your Service 60 Wonderbolts Academy 61 Apple Family Reunion
Granted some of the lower rankings seem a bit weird. I'm pretty sure I did not intentionally rank Wonderbolt Academy below Dragon Quest and Spike at Your Service. | |
|
| |
Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. | |
| |
|
| |
| A guy on reddit did a survey for best pony. | |
|